Unsustainable agricultural development in Malaysia. (Photo by R. Butler)
SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE TROPICS
By Rhett Butler
| Last updated July 22, 2012
In seeking a "solution" to deforestation of tropical rainforests—whether it be through debt-for-nature-swaps,
extractive reserves, selective logging, ecotourism, or another strategy—the ultimate fate of forests rests in
the hands of local people. While some would argue that rainforests can be "saved" by restricting economic
growth, it is necessary to realize that parks and reserves will not persist unless local communities are persuaded that
it is in their material interest to conserve.
For thousands of years tropical rainforests have been managed to sustain productive agriculture and at times to support
dense human populations. It is estimated that more land was under cultivation in the Amazon on the eve of the arrival
of Columbus than is today. Studies suggest that perhaps 12 percent of Amazonian terra firme (upland) forests are "anthropogenic
in nature, resulting from prolonged management by prehistoric populations." The fact that certain forms of
agriculture are possible is a vital consideration for the sustainable, economic development of tropical rainforests.
Rainforests have a long history of disturbance by humans who promoted areas of concentrated diversity of useful
species within a diverse landscape. Without undermining the ecological basis of production, indigenous communities
promoted the abundance of certain valuable species by creating conditions favoring their growth and development.
They fostered palm forests, groves of Brazil nuts and fruit trees, and vine forests near ancient Amazonian settlements
(past settlements are marked by the presence of pottery and anthropogenic "black soils"). These vegetation
types have species useful for everyday life.
Today we can incorporate the techniques of indigenous peoples into agricultural projects in the rainforest to increase
the productivity of degraded forest lands and promote sustainable use of forest resources. Through agroforestry
and floodplain orchards, outright destruction of rainforests can be avoided, while improving economic efficiency
and providing a source of income for rural poor.
Roughly a third to two-fifths of rainforest deforestation is caused by the shifted cultivator, who is usually pushed to marginal lands by
lack of other suitable land. In some areas these farmers may be forced into the forests as a result of population
growth and by landowners who hold large tracts of farmland. In many countries, wealthy landholders—who have
the most political clout—control the most productive lands, leaving the small farmers little choice but to clear a
homestead from the forest. For example, in Brazil, 10 percent of the population owns almost 90 percent of the fertile land. In
many countries, the politically expedient way of dealing with this skewed land distribution has been to open up
"unused" wildlands for poor farmers, rather than confront large landowners.
Some argue that some form of agrarian land reform is the best way to attack forest loss caused by "swidden
agriculture." Land reform may turn some productive land over to poor farmers and be accomplished by reducing
subsidies granted to large landowners for leaving tracts of their land uncultivated.
Slash-and-burn agriculture in the rainforest of Borneo
An additional, potentially complementary, approach to addressing the needs of the shifted cultivator and agriculturist alike is improving
and intensifying currently existing agricultural projects and promoting alternative cultivation techniques—notably
agroforestry—based on those used by indigenous forest dwellers. Many cleared forest areas used for agriculture
and now in decline can be salvaged by cultivation techniques that loosely mimic the diversity of the surrounding
rainforest. In other words, polycultural fields—patchworks of perennial crops, annual crops, pasture land, secondary
growth, and forest—could be the key to increasing agricultural productivity and reducing destruction in many
Historically, agriculture in the Amazon rainforest has had a highly dynamic nature whether it be on a grand scale
or at a subsistence level. Today a good deal of rainforest agriculture consists of monocultures (single crop fields)
of annual crops, which must be replanted on a regular basis to sustain yields. Poor tropical soils quickly wear
out under a regime of annuals, and fertilizers must be added or additional forest cleared if growth
is to continue.
Many forest dwellers instead focus on perennials—crops which continue
to produce for a number of years like citrus, manioc, vanilla, banana, mango, pepper, cacao, coffee, and rubber—as the basis of their agricultural techniques. Instead of continually clearing new sections of forest, these
cultivators plant perennials or a mixture of perennials and annuals on their patch of land. Perennials can help
restore nutrients to degraded soils, and they remain productive for decades, bringing a steady stream of cash to needy
A mixture of perennials and annuals often works best for small agricultural plots because such polycultural fields provide
a diversified income (prices of many cash crops are notoriously volatile), as well as insurance if one crop fails. The
home gardens of many forest dwellers are one form of agriculture well-suited to the rainforest environment. These
diverse agroforestry systems provide a wealth of plant species—both local and foreign, since tropical plants like mango,
pineapple, manioc, papaya, and orange have almost cosmopolitan distribution today. These species are also useful in everyday life. Home
gardens can serve as a living pharmacy and a local hardware store, while providing shade for humans and livestock,
foods for the kitchen, and ornamentals. Many home gardens contain remnants from old-growth forest in that useful
forest trees (like Brazil nuts) are often left standing when clearing a homestead.
An added bonus of such agroforestry systems is that they maintain forest systems, soils, and biological diversity at
a far higher level than do industrial agricultural techniques. As long as such fields are adjacent to secondary
and old-growth forest, many species will continue to thrive. Growing crops like coffee, cocoa, bananas, and vanilla in the
shade of canopy trees preserves more biodiversity than standard cultivation techniques. In recent years, "rainforest-friendly"
coffee has gained popularity and is now heavily promoted in some parts of the United States. Polycultural fields
also recover considerably faster than conventional fields when they are abandoned, because forest systems are maintained, including hydrological cycles, nutrient recycling, and seed dispersal.
Additionally, seed banks in the
soil persist and crop trees provide shade necessary for canopy tree-seed generation, allowing a relatively smooth
transition to secondary forest once the farmer moves on to a new area.
Despite all these positives, sustainable agriculture faces several hurdles in reaching widespread acceptance. Agroforestry
and other forms of reduced-impact agriculture are more attuned to the ecological realities than most forms of agriculture
in the rainforest, but they must also be attuned to economic realities. For example, many migrants to the rainforest
are ignorant of such cultivation methods. Instead—assuming they even know anything of agricultural techniques—they often rely on what works in different climates and soil conditions—methods that typically fail on cleared
Thus, one major challenge in promoting agroforestry is overcoming the ignorance of people who may have migrated to forest areas from cities about
farming techniques that are effective in tropical areas. A second obstacle is the lack of access for many rural poor. Without means to transport
their goods to market or even a market for their goods, locals have little chance of turning a profit for their
labor. Another issue is a general lack of credit facilities from which poor farmers can borrow in times of
need. Overcoming these obstacles—whether through improvement of existing roads, education systems, microfinance,
or other means—will bring us much closer to resolving the shifted-cultivator problem.
Agroforestry techniques can be applied on a larger scale using corridors of forest and a mixture of perennials
and annuals. While management and harvesting costs generally increase, these negatives could be outweighed by
the value of income diversification, soil protection, maintenance of forest functions, and preservation of biodiversity.
Sustainable agriculture is one of many means that can offer economic survival to landless poor and industry. Sustainable
development through harvesting of the forests' renewable resources has potential for saving rainforests by providing tangible
returns in the short run.
- Why are agriculture techniques important to the future of rainforests?
- What can we learn from past cultures about agriculture in the Amazon?
Other versions of this page
spanish | french | portuguese | chinese | japanese
Continued / Next:
Other pages in this section:
Selection of information sources
The list of non-wood forest products is taken from State of the World's Forests 1999 (SOFO) published by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO).
Examples of sustainable harvest values come from studies in Peru (Peters, C.M., Gentry, A.H., and Mendelsohn, R.O., "Valuation of an Amazonian Rainforest," Nature Vol. 339: 655-656 1989) and Ecuador (Grimes, A. et al., "Valuing the rain forest: the economic value of nontimber forest products in Ecuador," Ambio Vol. 23 No. 7, Nov. 1994).
Initiative to restore 50M acres of degraded Latin American ecosystems by 2020
(12/07/2014) A coalition of governments and organizations today pledged to restore 20 million hectares (50 million acres) of degraded forests and ecosystems across Latin America by 2020 under an initiative that aims to curb boost rural incomes, fight climate change, and increase agricultural production. The effort is backed by $365 million from five impact investors.
Central Kalimantan to set up palm oil monitoring system to in bid cut deforestation 80%
(10/05/2014) The Indonesian province of Central Kalimantan is moving forward on an oil palm plantation monitoring system it hopes will help meet a commitment to reduce deforestation 80 percent by 2020. The online monitoring system will include "information on the performance of plantation concessions such as productivity, the number of smallholder farmers, deforestation and other land cover change, and fire occurrence," according to Earth Innovation Institute which designed and is helping the provincial government implement the system.
How do we save the world's vanishing old-growth forests?
(08/26/2014) There's nothing in the world like a primary forest, which has never been industrially logged or cleared by humans. They are often described as cathedral-like, due to pillar-like trees and carpet-like undergrowth. Yet, the world's primary forests—also known as old-growth forests—are falling every year, and policy-makers are not doing enough to stop it.
More news on sustainable development
More rainforest news